Grading is based on one original post and one response. These two posts add up to ten points per week. The criteria are as follows: Completion; please refrain from poor grammar, poor spelling, and internet shorthand. Reference; mention the text or post to which the reply is directed. Personality; show thoughtfulness, care, and a sense of originality. Cohesiveness; The student should explain his or her thought without adding "fluff" merely to meet the requirement.
Thursday, February 16, 2012
-The Other Side-
I read The Other Side of the Hedge the other day and this maybe be way off but it kind of reminded me of Pilgrims Progress. That story was in my mind the whole time I was reading this one. It was similar in the way that both characters are on this journey to heaven. Both encounter characters that struggle with staying on the path and could be a discouragement to him. Both journeys are long and painful but are completed with the hope of something better at the end.Is this the story of our lives??
Commented on Tori's:)
02/16/2012
There is one thing that really stands out to me. It might not be on track with what was meant to come across, but I really liked it. When the writer is setting up the story, he tells about his brother. He says his brother "wasted his breath on singing, and his strength on helping others." He goes on to say that he had traveled "more wisely" and about the monotony of the highway. He even points out the cracks in the road that he has seen over and over.
The only thing I could think of when I read this was the two sides of a local church. On one side you have the church member that is always at church. They have their same seat they sit in every week and they talk to the same people. They like to know what songs will be sung and what will be preached. They like being comfortable in their predictable lives.
Then you have the other side that wants to break away from this cycle of going through the motions and simply "doing church". They want to, as the reading said, focus their "breath on singing, and [their] strength on helping others".
Thoughts?
"We won't be satisfied with anything ordinary, we won't be satisfied at all."
commented on Anna's "Drawn to the Hedge"
Casting stones
One of the more obvious things to mention is Inez, Garcin, and Estelle. These people are eternally doomed to be in the same room as one another. They all are trying to hide the reason each is in the room, but they eventually fess up.What I think is interesting about this situation is that even after death, pride and arrogance are still among these folks. They even look for mirrors in the room to get away from each other's constant stare of judgement. I think Sarte intended them to be this way to help illustrate his straight-forward approach in philosophy. It boils down to the fact that they had to face the truth, and could no longer hide behind themselves or their wrong doings.
p.s. commented on Hope??? by NickHampton
Oh, I can burp my ABCs...A...B...C...
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Hope???
When Living Becomes Life
No Exit. O.O

No Exit.
I really enjoyed reading No Exit, I think that how completely twisted it was made it sort of intriguing.
I liked how each character played into the other ones weaknesses and they’re all so twisted in different ways it just makes for one big hot mess. I guess I just want to talk about how the different people relate to one another.
Garcin treated his wife horribly, and he did it for the sake of breaking her down. Inez did the same thing with her lover and with her cousin. Then there’s Estelle who has an insuppressible need to be wanted for the sake of being wanted, which is cruel because she strings along men with the intent to fulfill her own selfish need to feel like she’s desirable. I look at her cruelty and apply it to the others, like when Estelle is seeing Peter dancing with Olga she says “He belonged to me”, and I think that’s how all three of them viewed other people. As belonging that they could easily toy with and toss away and I think that’s the horror of their cruelty that they have no concern for life outside of themselves. I think that’s ultimately why they are in hell. Maybe that’s why hell, for them, is other people. They had no concern for toying with other people and that’s what they have to face for eternity: not just other people but other people who are just like them.
But what’s weird to me is that even though, in my opinion, they are so terrible to people they all are dependent on validation from other people. Estelle needs for Garcin to validate her physically, as a woman. She needs him to want her and to have his companionship in order to feel validated. At first Garcin needs Estelle to validate him in the sense he needed her to confirm that he wasn’t a coward, and then he needed the same thing from Inez. And Inez is probably the biggest mess of all because first off I feel like she needs to inflict pain on other people because cruelty is her identity, but she also seems to need to prey on impressionable women and kind of woo them into loving her in order to be satisfied. Like with Estelle, she acts like she has to have her and I think that is because of her need to draw her in… kind of like a spider and a fly.
Drawn to the Hedge
“ A little puff of air revived me. It seemed to come from the hedge; and, when I opened my eyes, there was a glint of light through the tangle of boughs and the dead leaves.” (The Other Side of the Hedge sections three and four).
P.S. I commented on Will's "The Other Side"
The Never Ending Race
P.s. commented on Danielle's
Drip...Drip...Drip
Hell is other people?
Although, I fully disagree with the author's hell, it was a very interesting picture. After all other people can very well seem like hellish torturers. I got chills thinking about be locked inside a room forever with two people who knew my flaws, and knew how to use that against me. It does seem like a hellish picture, forever never having rest, constantly having those people jabbing at you. What was the author's meaning here?
Was he trying to make a point? All three of the characters were cowards or disrespected human life. I mean a mother drowned her own baby! They also all did it for their selfish selves, either to protect themselves or empower themselves. To me, I felt the author was trying to say, respect other humans no matter who or what they are.
P.S. Commented on Kelsey's post
Huis Clos
P.S. Commented on Lane's
Alive and Moving
somebody let me come through, I'll always be there,
as frightened as you, to help us survive, being alive!"
-Stephen Sondheim, Being Alive from Company
Maybe this upcoming opera has got me in a really musical mood (as if I'm ever NOT) but as I read E.M. Forester's The Other Side of the Hedge the above song, Being Alive instantly came to mind. Though my details on the plot of the musical are sketchy, it's basically a dramedy about a man named Bobby who has troubles committing to adult relationships and finds himself, on his 35th birthday, confronted with everything in life he tries to avoid. Hilarious and heartbreaking situations follow, and Being Alive is the big closing number. Bobby originally starts the song misanthropic, reflecting his initial sentiments, and finishes with this final verse and chorus realizing the value of everyday life.
It's really quite a beautful song, and The Other Side of the Hedge is a beautiful poem, with connections to the song. Hedge examines the value of life and human existence from a more progressional standpoint, showing the protagonist jogging in the beginning along with many others before finally falling in the hedge. Within, she finds a sect of humanity that does not move but simply stands in place and does nothing. They simply stand around containing great amounts of potential but not using it at all, because that is supposedly the better way to live. Of course, that is not really living at all, and the heroine cries out "Give me life, with its struggles and victories, with its failures and hatreds, with its deep moral meaning and its unknown goal!" Suddenly, the El Dorado chapters in Candide have new meaning and weight. Suddenly, Candide's escape from the perfect city of peace becomes not a selfish endeavour but the result of a deep and longing desire for something more than just comfort and inactivity. There is no life in El Dorado, true life is outside the hedge! I'm beginning that this distinction between apathy and action, between peace and tribulation, ultimately between stale life and true life is the ground upon which modernity makes its stand, and I look forward to seeing what Bonhoeffer and Faulkner do with this tension.
Thanks for reading, please feel free to comment as you wish. I commented on Josh Goldman's Apparently, the Hedge IS Greener On the Other Side.
Second-Guessing
This is something I do often, guessing something about a book, movie, or tv show at the very beginning. Normally, I either forget the thought I had or I decide I MUST be wrong. Most of the time it's because I'm hoping I'm wrong. The rest of the time though, it's because I'm sure my guess is too obvious and the real thing has to be more complicated. It makes me think of tests I've taken in the past where I've second-guessed myself and changed an answer, only to find out I was right in the first place.
I think I do this with God too often. I'll be sure He's telling me to do something and then second guess myself. I've been doing this for years with a calling to the mission field. He called me when I was 14, and I chose to answer that call. After a few months though, I decided that there was no way He wanted me to go out of the country for missions. Now though, I'm sure He does. Within recent years, I've been trying to not second-guess what God is calling me to do, but it's hard. Maybe it's time for me to stop second-guessing what I decipher about books, television, and movies and just try to accept what I've thought.
On a completely different note, I got a chance to spend the evening with Dr. Bear who is speaking tomorrow in Honors and I'm very excited about seeing her teach tomorrow. I have a feeling she will do great tomorrow, and this is something I WON'T second-guess!
Until next time,
~Meghan
P.S. I commented on Autumn's post
Apparently, the Hedge IS Greener on the Other Side
Let Me Outta Here!
So I find it suspiciously interesting that the week we celebrate love and friendship the Honors class is reading two stories dealing with death, just saying.
I just finished reading “The Other Side of the Hedge” and I find it interesting that while it is vaguely similar to “No Exit”, it’s also rather different, like two sides of the same coin. Judging by these two works, death is an ending. Not a reward or specific punishment depending on the life lived, just an ending where everyone sort of ends up eventually. Apparently death is also quite boring. I think the authors are maybe trying to say that there is no relief in death, for neither the good people nor the bad people. Death just… is. That kind of purposeless existence is awful. In both cases, the main character(s) try to escape back into life only to be barred from doing so. Clearly, they don’t want to be there. How terrible must it be if a life full of strife, toil, and unhappiness is better than death.
P.S.: i commented on Will's "The Other Side"
Call It Fate
I kept picturing the "Saw" series while I read this story. In the second movie of the series, all of the people keep questioning why they are there in the first place. One of the main characters, Amanda says that they are all in there for a reason. They all begin to start questioning why everyone is in there much like what Garcin, Inez, and Estelle do in the play. None of the characters are in there by chance. There is a reason why Satan or Jigsaw from "Saw" put all of them in there together. They all committed horrific acts and needed to be punished. Jigsaw put the characters in their own idea of Hell while these characters from "No Exit" are actually in Hell. Though I wish that the Hell in "No Exit" had been worse. I feel like Garcin, Inez, and Estelle needed a greater punishment.
P.S. I commented on His Beloved's post, "Call Me Crazy, but..."
the path less traveled
p.s. Rachel’s Blah Blah -Authentic Self
"Is this Transcendence?"
Which Side of the Hedge Are You On?
Call me crazy, but....
p.s I commented on Jamie's post "Random thoughts on No Exit"
Random thoughts on "No Exit"
The Other Side
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Blah Blah- Authentic Self.
Unfulfilling Confirmation VS The Only Fulfilling Confirmation
I also liked when Dr. Abernathy said, if you need a mirror or someone to confirm you, you don’t know who you are. It takes me back to the verse in James 1:23 - “For if anyone is a hearer of the word and not a doer, he is like a man who looks intently at his natural face in a mirror.” This verse is rather self-explanatory so I will just leave it at that for whoever reads this to think upon. How often do we hear the word of God but then after hearing it stop there? We feel His leading but turn a deaf heart, ear, mind, or body of service to Him?.
Ps - Lane