Grading is based on one original post and one response. These two posts add up to ten points per week. The criteria are as follows: Completion; please refrain from poor grammar, poor spelling, and internet shorthand. Reference; mention the text or post to which the reply is directed. Personality; show thoughtfulness, care, and a sense of originality. Cohesiveness; The student should explain his or her thought without adding "fluff" merely to meet the requirement.
Thursday, April 19, 2012
Jews, Binx and Romantics
The Big Picture
I commented on Nickhampton's Model Tenant/Citizen???
Truth
P.S commented on Danielle's Post
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
Model Tenant/Citizen???
on being a doctor and ecclesiastes.
All is Vanity
Popcorn! (Cause it's the moviegoer and all that...yea)
Commented on Lane's
Comment on Will's
The Moviegoer and Wise Blood
Searching before it was Mainstream.
what has been done will be done again;
there is nothing new under the sun.
Is there anything of which one can say,
'Look! This is something new'?
It was here already, long ago;
it was here before our time.
No one remembers the former generations,
and even those yet to come
will not be remembered
by those who follow them."
Ohh, Kate...
She tries to end her life on multiple occasions, but then never follows through with it. She claims that suicide is, in fact, the only thing keeping her alive. The fact is, she can't commit suicide because she is so deep in despair. Kierkegaard calls this torment of losing the inability to die, to die death.
"... this sickness of the self, perpetually to be dying, to die and yet not die. For to die signifies that it is all over, but to die death means to experience death means to experience dying, and if this is experienced for one single moment, one thereby experiences it forever."
Now imagine living (if you could even call it living) in this "sickness unto death". Imagine no longer wanting to live, but without even death to look forward to. Suddenly, Kate is a little more understandable. But this is where God comes in. In my paper, I talked about why Percy didn't "end the novel with Binx at the altar of the local Catholic church." He wanted Binx's search to spark his readers' searches without their knowledge. He wanted them to find their way to God on their own. Kate also had to discover this on her own, Binx couldn't do it for her.
Great day in the morning!
This quote made me reflect on my love of traveling. For some reason, when I travel, even if I simply rest- I don't sightsee or run around- I come back tired (yet energized). I think Percy hit on the reason for this, because if you go somewhere and you experience the journey and the place and the people... then you are impacted. You share life with the people surrounding you through conversation and "regular" interaction. When you are in a new place, "regular" interaction is not mundane- it's charged with a taste of adventure and novelty. Even if the place you go does not involve a different culture or people who are drastically different, there is still the process of figuring out where things are and how to get there. It's tiring to experience all these things, but for me it's also energizing because I love learning about people and I enjoy the disruption of mundane routine. Being in a new place results in new thoughts and a different way of looking at things, because you are taken out of the everydayness and placed in a situation that requires a reaction. I believe Percy would also call traveling a relief from everyday deadness and a bit of life... if one experiences travels in the right way and seasons them with some risk and adventure.
On the other hand, if someone hops on a plane and jumps around from place to place, their head in the clouds or wrapped up in their own concerns, they do not experience the place or the people. Traveling is not meant to be a selfish thing but a learning experience. If it's a selfish journey then there is no discovery of self and no real journey has been taken.
p.s. I still do not understand the phrase "Great day in the morning" ...I had a teacher in elementary school who said that all the time!
p.p.s. commented on Rachel's Lip Piercing
What Mitchell said.
The Search cannot be conquered alone
Walker Percy creates a cosmos in which human interaction is necessary. He presents man as a being which is unique, unlike that of any other creature. In his Lost in the Cosmos, he speaks of how, although man has continually tried to prove that other animals have the capacity to learn language, all attempts have fallen short (“Cosmos” 94). Moreover, it is this uniqueness of man that allows him to have an added dimension to his interaction with others and the world. You can teach a pigeon a command, or condition them to make a certain response. Take for example B.F. Skinner’s pigeons who learned to match a particular color to the word for that color in order to receive food. But, with man there is another level of interaction which can never occur with a pigeon, or any other animal; “The human's behavior cannot be understood within the S-R paradigm because there is no direct relation between the sound "ball" and the ball itself, nor is the learning of the relation a conditioned response." When man sees the name of a color he does not recognize it as a trigger into action, but instead he is able to recognize the meaning behind the letters, he sees the word as a symbol/ sign representing something else.
Now, this ability of man to use signs makes him a triadic being. In other words, for man to use language, there are three necessary parts: a signifier (the one introducing the sign), a referent (the object or thing which the sign is referring to), and Dasein (the being who is receiving it) (“Cosmos” 95). Therefore, “all such triadic behavior is social in origin,” for there must be someone to introduce the sign (96). As Percy states, “A signal received by an organism is like other signals or stimuli from its environment. But a sign requires a sign giver. Thus, every triad of sign-reception requires another triad of sign-utterance” (“Cosmos” 96).
So it is understood that Percy believes human interaction is necessary for the use of language, but does this mean that he believes interaction is necessary for one to know their Self?
The answer to this question can be found within Percy’s “Space Odyssey”s. In these provocative short stories, he speaks of one’s own consciousness of Self as being completely dependent on the use of language:
“…in order for the individual consciousness to be activated, it is required that there be a Soc, that is a society, that is, two or more persons; an exchange of Sy, that is symbols; and an Int, that is, an intersubjective relationship in which there is agreement about the symbol used and the thing that is talked about” (“Cosmos” 208).
Therefore, for Percy it is crucial that one have this meaningful interaction of signs if they are to become aware of and ultimately come to know their Self. To take this interaction away would be to deprive man of something “profoundly and uniquely human” (Poteat 10).
Furthermore, in The Moviegoer, one can see Percy’s theories in action. His character Kate has a lost Self. She is constantly troubled by who she is, and ultimately in the end of the novel asks Binx to marry her so that he can continually tell her who she is and what she is supposed to be doing.
Binx: “… I should tell you what to do?”
Kate: “Yes. It may not be the noblest way of living, but it is one way. It is my way! Oh dear sweet old Binx, what a joy it is to discover at last what one is. It doesn’t matter what you are as long as you know” (Percy 196).
Moreover, this marriage does not only have a purpose in Kate’s search for self, but it also has a purpose in Binx’s search as well. It is not until Binx opens himself up to a vulnerable relationship with Kate that he is able to truly rise above the fog of the malaise for the second time in his life. “There I see her plain, see plain for the first time since I lay wounded in a ditch and watched an oriental finch scratching around in the leaves…” (Percy 206). Therefore, one cannot wrest the Self from the everydayness without accepting the help of another. The search cannot be conquered alone.
I commented on Josh Spell's Blog "The Matrix and the Moviegoer"
Heightened Senses
Wanting Tragedy
Crystal Clear
P.S. I commented on Joy's post, "Guest Speaker."
The Matrix and The Moviegoer
Binx doesn't like that. Discontent with the world he sees, he searches for something, though he knows not for what he searches. This search is the plot of Walker Percy's Moviegoer, a 1960 novel that is not unlike the Wachowski brothers' Matrix, a 1999 action film. From a strict sci-fi perspective, The Matrix is a pretty cool movie, but underneath its action-packed exterior is a world of philosophical depth.
Like Binx Bolling, Thomas Anderson (Neo) is an upright, respectable citizen. He has a Social Security number, pays his taxes and helps the landlady take out her garbage, and like Binx, he comes to think the world is a lie. He too is searching for something, and this prompts the question: "What is the Matrix?" Neo goes to the sage Morpheus, who tells him:
The Matrix is a system, Neo. The system is our enemy... You can see it when you look out your window or turn on your television. You can feel it when you go to work, when you go to church, when you pay your taxes. It is the world that has been pulled over your eyes to blind you from the truth.Morpheus holds out his hands. One contains a blue pill, and the other, a red. He makes Neo choose.
You take the blue pill- the story ends, you wake up in your bed and believe whatever you want to believe. You take the red pill- you stay in Wonderland, and I show you how deep the rabbit hole goes. Remember, all I'm offering you is the truth.
![]() |
"The Matrix is a system..." |
Binx believes that 98% of Americans have taken "the blue pill." Going against fashionable opinion, he questions. He searches. He takes "the red pill." He says,
What is the nature of the search...? The search is what anyone would undertake if he were not sunk in the everydayness of his own life... To become aware of the possibility of the search is to be onto something. Not to be onto something is to be in despair.While the worlds around them sink into blandness and despair, Binx and Neo question, which, according to Heidegger, is to be willing to know, and "to know" is not the accumulation of facts but to be willing to learn what knowledge he does not possess. He who thinks he knows does not "know," and he who does not know is far closer to "knowing" than he thinks.
This perpetual uncertainty about the establishments, systems and institutions that make up society is the very essence of postmodernism.
![]() |
What do you choose? |
The Gulf Coast Is Under the Sun

Binx the Existentialist
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
Lip Piercing
Guest Speaker
PS - Lane